Open wide!

Open wide!

The title of the article is: Man who shot cop he found in bed with his wife indicted for attempted murder. Reading the headline, it sounds like a guy cuckolded by an unfaithful spouse (and a horny cop) is about to be subjected to the further abuse of an unfair prosecution.

But that’s just a tad misleading. The key word missing from the headline: estranged wife. Kind of changes the complexion of the story, that.

The Staten Island man accused of shooting an NYPD detective he found in his estranged wife’s home has been indicted in Monmouth County, New Jersey.

A grand jury hit Robert Dunbar, 35, with attempted murder charges for allegedly grabbing the off-duty cop’s service weapon and firing of several shots, including one that hit the cop, Louis Pepe, in the back.

via Man who shot cop he found in bed with his wife indicted for attempted murder –

We’d suggest there are several ways to avoid winding up like Detective Pepe. One of the more obvious is to stick to beds where you know there are no rivals, er, gunning for you. Another, assuming you’ve decided that you absolutely must cuddle with some other dude’s wife (estranged or not; some guys have decidedly idiosyncratic views of marital exclusivity), is to put your pistol somewhere that is not immediately obvious to someone who enters the room and sees you putting the moves on his woman (and the cuckold’s horns on his head).

There are also several ways to avoid winding up like Mr Dunbar. The most universally applicable: when the woman wants out, be a gentleman and open the door for her. Most of men’s troubles come from the persistent delusion that one woman is materially different from the next. And then, there is the good old standby: don’t just go around shooting people. Yeah, those are a bit on the “too obvious” side. But this guy didn’t see them, for all that. Now the entire trajectory of his life is in the hands of a jury and the random quasi-justice of American courts, and it’s all his own fault.

This entry was posted in Don’t be THAT guy on by Hognose.

About Hognose

Former Special Forces 11B2S, later 18B, weapons man. (Also served in intelligence and operations jobs in SF).

2 thoughts on “Calling this ‘Defensive Gun Use’ is a stretch


Someone in bed with your estranged wife or former paramour is not your enemy, but your best friend. They’ve either saved you from a terrible mistake, or decades of alimony.

Despite the lizard-brain response to such shenanigans, the only thing one should be shooting upon such a situation, is pictures.

Lots and lots of pictures.

(For the record, numerous mostly Southern states, taking a slightly more traditional view, regard the killing of only one party in such a case to be second-degree (unpremeditated) murder, whereas killing them BOTH on the spot is chargeable only as a crime of passion and aggravated manslaughter, with suitably less serious consequences. Purely for informational purposes, and presuming your marksmanship skills are more advanced than those in the referenced story.)

Tom Schultz

I believe the old Texas “he/she needed killin’” defense has gone by the wayside. But in some Southern states, as Aesop refers. still have the sporting question. “Did he shoot him on the rise?”