Category Archives: Unconventional Warfare

Terrorist might do 2 years for 4 bomb murders

One John Anthony Downey is under arrest as British prosecutors seek to close a 1982 mass murder by IRA terrorists. In July, 1982, they charge, he set and detonated a massive car bomb that destroyed an element of one of the units that guards Buckingham Palace. The bomb, one of two coordinated bombs set by the IRA in London’s Hyde and Regent Parks that day, killed seven horses and three men, two of them just married; a fourth member of the Blues and Royals died of his wounds four days later. Many other men and at least one horse suffered serious wounds.

John Downey, from County Donegal in the Republic of Ireland, is accused of being responsible for the car bomb that targeted a troop of the Royal Household Cavalry, Blues and Royals, as they rode from their barracks to Buckingham Palace.

Mr Downey is charged with the murders of Squadron Quartermaster Corporal Roy Bright, 36, Lieutenant Anthony Daly, 23, Trooper Simon Tipper, 19, and Lance Corporal Jeffrey Young, 19, on July 20 1982.

Sue Hemming, the Crown Prosecution Service’s head of special crime and counter-terrorism, said: “The Metropolitan Police Service has been investigating the explosion near Hyde Park in London which occurred on July 20 1982.

“It is alleged that Downey is responsible for the improvised explosive device contained in a car parked in South Carriage Drive, London, which resulted in the deaths of four members of the Royal Household Cavalry, Blues and Royals, as they travelled on their daily route from their barracks to Buckingham Palace.”

via Man, 61, charged with murdering four soldiers in IRA’s 1982 Hyde Park bombing – Telegraph.

But thanks to an agreement the British Government and the terrorists reached in 1998, Downey need not be acquitted to get out of jail soon. If Downey is convicted, he can apply for a transfer to a prison in Northern Ireland (rather than one in England, where most of London’s murderers end up). Then he can apply for release after two years, regardless of his nominal sentence.

Meanwhile, of course, Downey’s victims are still dead, and their family members are still bereaved. Not that any of the IRA goons (or the Protestant terrorist goons, who were as bad and arguably worse) gives a damn about them. 

The British were handling terrorism better when they were just having the SAS show up and blow these creeps away. Go easy on terrorism, and what do you get? Most everybody has seen the news from Woolwich. That’s what you get.  It’s almost as if the nation had a suicide pact with its political elite.

About those searches in Watertown

A lot of people are talking about the searches in Watertown, MA. Here’s a typical report from a right-leaning news site, complete with an embedded video that makes it look like something out of some black-hearted European dictatorship or other.

The police came to people’s homes, ordered them to leave immediately at the point of a gun in some cases, and then entered their place of residence. It’s never “consensual” when the person asking you for something has a gun in his hand. “Probable cause” is convenient, but in this case, very arbitrary.

Would you believe, the searches were not like the media has portrayed them? We know, the media have been so crowned with glory in this it’s hard to believe they got some facts wrong, eh? But here are some other facts that have not been in the media. Our local SWAT guys (a regional team) were part of this, as cops were called in from many miles around. And here’s what their instructions were, paraphrased:

  1. Keep safe, but ask whoever answers the door for permission to search. (Most homeowners voluntarily exited and let the police search).
  2. If the homeowner refuses, look for signs of duress.
  3. Absent signs of duress, try to convince them to let you search.
  4. If they continue to deny permission, and are not under duress, thank them for their time and move on.

It doesn’t seem wise to pass on the “event of duress” instructions. As it happened there were no such persons under duress. Two homeowners refused consent, and their homes were not entered or searched. They both said that they had searched their own premises and Flashbang was not hiding within. (This was a little alarming to the cops, who had visions of some unprepared householder coming across a man of such demonstrated violence… but no such event happened).

They followed these instructions, and made a point of thanking householders and apologizing for the intrusion, which may cut no ice with Constitutional lawyers, but goes a long way with the living, breathing members of the actual public. The cops were keenly aware that these were not crack houses, but honest citizens, and they had been quietly told, quote, “you’re not looking for contraband, you’re looking for the terrorist or evidence he was there, period.” Now, this is just one team of many, which searched only a handful of the hundreds of residences inspected, but it’s hard to believe that these cops were the only good and decent ones of the assembled army.

So these weren’t warrantless searches, they were consent searches, a very different animal. The above-linked column suggests that you can never really consent when the man at your door has a gun in his hand. Against that, we offer the fact that people did not consent, and no harm came to them.

There’s plenty to criticize the Massachusetts authorities over. They’re still stonewalling on the records of just how much welfare and school aid the bombers were getting, but they were both living middle-class lives without ever having held a job, so you do the math. And it really looks like the authorities (including the same Federal prosecutor who hounded Aaron Swartz to his death, and then made jokes about it) are going to botch Flashbang’s trial. But the search is not in that class of government misfeasance. If you think that what happened in Watertown was “Gestapo tactics,” you need to hit the books on how the Gestapo and other totalitarian secret police in general operated.

We’re holding out for “John has a Long Moustache”

Somebody in one of those tactical patch vendors has a sense of humor, and an appreciation of 1980s guerilla warfare movies. They’ll sell you this for $6:

 It’s 11:59 on Radio Free America; this is Uncle Sam, with music, and the truth until dawn. Right now I’ve got a few words for some of our brothers and sisters in the occupied zone: “the chair is against the wall, the chair is against the wall”

A tribute to one of the greatest movies ever, Red Dawn!

PVC, velcro backed, and approximately 2″ x 3″ in size. Available in Coyote and Black, Grey and Black, and Camo.

We hear that the Powers That Bees are cracking down on display of morale patches, and there’s currently a sergeants-majors’ jihad against that garment inimical to good order and discipline, the baseball cap. These things go in circles. When the Army was in dopey green baseball caps (which were worn with your rank and unit crest pinned on, just to take the dopey to 11), SF guys liked to wear their Ranger caps (same-same current patrol cap, but OD Green) in garrison just because it was forbidden. Now that the Army is in patrol caps (and black issued-not-earned berets), SF guys like tan baseball caps. All that was old is new again. In WWII it was the angle of your overseas cap;  we wonder what it was for Napoleon’s Guards or Caesar’s legionaries. The combat soldier has to have something to push back against the overhead and the teeming grifters of the rear area.

via The Chair is Against the Wall Patch. Tell ‘em WeaponsMan sent ya.

Terrorist Roundup

Terrorist Buster logoTerrorists Everywhere!

A cynic might note that if you pay people to track, monitor, handle, arrest, or disrupt terrorists, you’re going to have more “terrorists” than you can shake a stick at. And the cynic might be right, because an unusually broad and eclectic range of terrorists have been in the headlines lately. Nazis. Jihadis. Trailer trash. Et cetera, et cetera. Unfortunately, they haven’t been making the news the way we like: with a couple of Seal Six guys conducting a cable-news war of attrition, about who gets the credit for capping them.

German Nazi Terrorists!

Nazi flagSpanning the world, to bring you a look at the wide range of dysfunctional and degenerate humanity that gets stickered with the all-purpose cautionary label, “terrorist.” First, we’ve got a neo-Nazi woman terrorist in the dock in Germany. So they’re not entirely a creation of nebbishy Hollywood screenwriters’ bad dreams! Who knew? The Nazis and their wannabes were pretty much extinct in the Bundesrepublik before the Wiedervereinigung, but they’re back like the raptors in a weaker Jurassic Park sequel – “the second time, as farce.” Only it probably wasn’t funny to their victims. No better place to learn about Nazis than Der Bloomführer’s news agency:

The trial of Beate Zschaepe, a member of a neo-Nazi cell accused of a series of xenophobic murders, opened in Munich today — after weeks in which public attention focused more on the court’s media policy than the charges.

The National Socialist Underground, or NSU, allegedly killed the 10 people as part of a plan to terrorize minorities and force them to leave the country. Eight of those murdered between 2000 and 2006 were of Turkish origin. The others were a Greek man and a German policewoman. The killing spree came to light in November 2011 after Zschaepe’s companions, Uwe Boehnhardt and Uwe Mundlos, committed suicide in a camper van in eastern Germany.

For some reason, the Bloom Shirts think this trial is not about murders, but about the Germans having insulted the Holy Media. What next, they cooked their schnitzel in trans fats?

Times change; we remember when NSU in Germany meant an interesting, but undependable, car, with a Wankel engine before Wankels were cool — before Mazda applied Japanese reliability engineering to the design, and made it stop emitting blue oil smoke.

Boston Jihad Terrorists!

There’s all kinds of news about Flashbang and Speedbump, but we’re mostly interested in the how, and in laughing about how the media are puzzled by the glaringly clear why. One more piece of the puzzle comes in with the probable time and location of their test blasts, along with some new potential accessories/co-conspirators, coming to light. See here on ViralRead and more analysis of probabilities at the Jester’s page. (Any successful bomber tends to have done tests, and that’s usually very important to putting the sonofallah away).

Minnesota trailer-trash “terrorist”!

ap106761484462The FBI is calling this loser a “terrorist,” but it seems like the word doesn’t mean what they think it means. He’s a 24-year-old career small-time criminal who apparently intended to off someone or -ones with an illegally owned AK and a collection of molotovs and pipe bombs. In other words, he was a typical resident of South Side Chicago, a state or two out of place.

It’s almost as if someone gave the Bureau the Word to “find some terrorist who never cared what direction Mecca is in.” And they did!

Geezer Hippie Terrorist!

And the poster child for the narcissistic-rich-kids’-tantrum-of-the-seventies, the Weather Underground, Bill Ayers, made an appearance at Kent State to hog the spotlight in classic Baby Boomer fashion, and say his years of terror bombing were just a sensible, legitimate reaction to the horrors of the Vietnam War. He now claims that various bombs that failed to kill people were not intended to kill people. (So why did he pack them with shrapnel… was he trying to be a high-explosive Jackson Pollock?)

Even as a terrorist, Ayers was more jacked up than Flashbang and Speedbump. He was a Gilbert & Sullivan revolutionary.

But we shouldn’t lose sight of his intentions, of which he repents not. Let’s even take him at his word, that Vietnam animated his terrorism, but let’s unpack what he means by that. Remember, this crumb was on the side of the people who left 5,000 dead civilians, hands bound, in mass graves in Hue in Tet ’68. He stood with the functionaries who introduced the words Re-Education Camp to international discourse. His objection to to our efforts in Vietnam was to the delay in his side’s program of mass murder and brainwashing. If his guys were any better than Hitler, we’re damned if we can see how.

Most pitiful: his attempt to sell himself as young. One of the most unseemly of the Boomers’ pathologies is their endless and futile quest for youth. Gramps, you’re retirement age. Retire already.

And worse, Terrorologists!

And just when you thought it was safe to go back into the water, we get the word that smacked-down phony SF/Ranger/Spetsnaz-shovel-slinger and self-credentialed “terrorologist,” not to mention the world’s only expert in hostage negotiation that’s gotten that way without training or experience, is back on the scene again, selling his dubious expertise. Yep, John Giduck, PhD, which in his case stands for Phony Douchebag even though he’s also a Doctor of Philosophy from some overseas diploma mill, is baaaack… and trying to weasel out of the attorneys’ fees he was ordered to pay after his last SLAPP suit. Supposedly, he’s now an expert in Chechnya. Well, it alliterates with Cha-Chingg! we guess.

Paying John Giduck to share his knowledge with you is right up there with lending Flashbang and Speedbump your pressure cooker.

Is the gun blogosphere dying?

“Sebastian” at the excellent PA Gun Blog thinks so, that it’s become so difficult for new blood to break in that overall quality is declining. He says:

I think it comes down to several factors, as to why it’s difficult:

  • The death of the Pingback, and ability to reliably trace incoming links. You can now do this with Google, but it also catches a lot of junk. Spammers have largely killed our ability to see who’s linking us. This makes it harder to notice new upstarts who are looking to join the conversation.
  • The signal-to-noise ratio in blogging seems to be a lot higher now than it was when I started. When I started, there were fewer blogs, and many of them had pretty reasonable audiences. It was pretty easy to keep track of who was saying what, and joining the conversation was a lot easier.
  • The entrance of commercial blogs and SEO schucksters into the game. These sites have to view themselves as destinations, because that’s how you make money. There are multiple examples of these even in the gun blogosphere, and you know who they are. This is very good for those destination sites, but it’s a horrible thing for the blogging community.

There is also a tendency, when you’ve been blogging for quite some time, to get set in your ways. You get it down to a routine, and to some degree you have to do it that way to save time. I have 2-4 hours a day to spend on blogging. That’s about it. So you combine that with a higher signal-to-noise ratio, and no great way to see who’s saying what out there (because pingbacks and Google alerts are mostly junk from spammers or other ‘noise’), and the result is less linkage, except to the blogs I’ve been reading since before I was blogging, or who started around the same time I did.

via Shall Not Be Questioned.

He refers back (via clinical law prof Bill Jacobson) to this article by Stacy McCain, that suggests that if you see your blog as a destination, rather than as a portal to other bloggers, it’s going to be hard to break in.

We reckon it depends on what you want. There are guys that serially start up blogs, and then sell them off to operators that turn them into ad farms, and run them until the residual good will is gone. You guys know who we mean.

Some of the commercial blogs are known for lifting your stuff and not linking you. Eh. We always try to link the originator of a story, and we hope for linkbacks, but we’ve noticed some sites never do. We link them less. McCain has the right idea there, and we’ve been known to hit his tip jar (as well as having bought him a beer in person), but we’ve seldom linked to him — he’s a political blog, of limited utility to our gun and special operations focus. So naturally, he’s never linked us back. (Maybe we should link him, now that his son is an 18X. If Junior can beat the odds and not wind up in the 82nd — NTTAWWT — he’ll be practically family).

Norks take a hostage…seven, actually

HRH Kim II (illustrated) inspires the Regime of Perpetual Kims

The spirit of  sainted HRH Kim II (illustrated) inspires the Regime of Perpetual Kim Asshattery today. Unfortunately, the clowns are armed and dangerous.

The Chosun Ilbo (S. Korean news) reports that the Norks have taken an American of Korean descent prisoner, in what the Norks call “an arrest for crimes against the state” but the South, including the Ilbo, see as hostage-taking:

Korean American tourist Kenneth Bae has been detained there for unspecified crimes against the state since November last year.

The North Korean committee overseeing the joint industrial park on the day did not interfere with the evacuation and merely issued a statement saying it is “concerned” about the way things are going.

via The Chosun Ilbo (English Edition): Daily News from Korea – N.Korea Reheats Hostage Ploy.

In addition to Bae, seven South Korean managers and workers at the now-closed international Kaesong Industrial Complex were taken hostage.

HRH Kim III demonstrates Nork range technology: Suddenly it's 1990!

HRH Kim III demonstrates Nork range technology: Suddenly it’s 1990! Dig the OD Green CRTs.

North Korea took hostages in 2009, including two American journalists, and was rewarded with appeasement — they called it “kowtowing” — from President Obama, who dispatched former President Clinton to bow down before then-king Kim II. Kim III gives every appearance of running plays from the ancestral playbook.

The Korean hostages, on the other hand, appear to be held for cash ransom. North Korea is demanding over $1 million each for their freedom, claiming that the state is owed back wages for North Korean slave laborers who worked in the now-defunct Kaesong industrial plants.

The plants are no use to North Korea. They depend on water and power from over the border, which is now cut off. North Korea has too little energy to supply its top-priority munitions factories, its Communist Party courtiers, and the Kaesong plant, too. And so, it doesn’t really seem to have enough money to restart the production that might bring it the hard currency to build a power plant or transmission lines.

Update: Bae has been sentenced for “crimes against the state.” Apparently without the bourgeois Western formality of a trial, not that the Norks could conduct one if they tried.

More details yet on the Boston bomb

Powder extracted from these fireworks powered the Boston bombers' devices. (Image: FBI)

Powder extracted from these fireworks powered the Boston bombers’ devices. (Image: FBI)

Here’s some information coming straight at you without media intervention. It comes from the PC affidavit for the arrest of one of Speedbump and Flashbang’s three inept co-conspirators, whom we’ll nickame in the spirit of Howie Carr: Dias Kadyrbayev (Here’s the gun angle the media’s seeking: DIAS = Drop-In Auto Sear?) Robel Phillipos (Dynamit Robel) and Azamat Tazhayakov (this one’s too easy: Hazmat).

On April 18th, 2013, between approximately 6:00 PM and 7:00 PM, Drop-In Auto Sear, Hazmat Manyletters, and Dynamit Robel met at the UMASS-Dartmouth campus and went to Flashbang’s dormitory room. Flashbang’s roommate let them in, stating that Flashbang had left a couple of hours earlier. Drop-in, Hazmat, and Dynamit spent some time inside the room watching a movie. They noticed a backpack containing fireworks. The fireworks had been opened and emptied of powder. Hazmat knew when he saw the fireworks that Flashbang had been involved in the Marathon bombing. Hazmat decided to remove the backpack from the room in order to help his friend Flashbang avoid trouble. He decided to take Flashbang’s laptop as well, because he did not want Flashbang’s roommate to think he was stealing or behaving suspiciously by just taking the backpack.

We’re thinking: if these guys are delayed in their collegiate education by a short detour to Cold Stone.edu for a short course, it won’t exactly be a loss to the field of rocket surgery. (It doesn’t seem likely they’ll go up for all that long: the FBI has not alleged any of them were involved in or had prior knowledge of the plot, only that they were accessories after the fact and conspired to obstruct justice). One also wonders about the unnamed roommate. He didn’t exactly knock himself out coming forward, but they haven’t charged him with anything.

Here’s the affidavit (.pdf), with Weaponsman’s compliments: Criminal-Complaint-Against-Robel-Phillipos. Hat tip, Stacy McCain. The image on the right of this post came from the affidavit; it’s the only photo included.

So we know what the containment was that they used: ordinary kitchen pressure cookers. (Wives and moms of Religion of Peace™ adherents, check your pantries). We know what deflagrant they used (black powder from these fireworks, illustrated). We know what shrapnel they used (BBs, more of which were recovered by the FBI from Flashbang’s dorm room). We know what inspired their design (Inspire, July 2010), and we know why they did it (the Religion of Peace™). We even know how they financed their jihad (they were all on the dole, off and on. Speedbump alone received some $96k in Section 8 benefits alone, although a total accounting has been hindered by Mass. governor Deval Patrick doing with the welfare records what Drop-in Auto Sear, Dynamit Robel and Hazmat tried to do with the evidence in Flashbang’s dorm room). The bombs themselves are a pretty clear picture by this point in time, with only the detonators lacking official documentation. That will come in due course, we think.

It’s a pretty long trip from the initial media reports, which suggested that the perps were Tea Party tax protesters using bombs made with gunpowder. While tax-protest cranks and right-wing oddballs have surely had some violent standoffs with government over the years, and one singleton anti-abortion bomber targeted a nonrelated gathering of civiians 20 years ago (Eric Rudolph, Atlanta Olympics), simultaneous multiple bombings of gatherings of civilians is claimed as a tactic by both Sunni and Shiite flavors of Islam worldwide.

Of course, right-wing terrorism is clearly a proportionate part of the problem. What proportion is made clear by viewing the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted Terrorist list. (For the record, the one guy on the list whose name doesn’t immediately suggest The Religion of Peace™ is a left-wing, animal-rights terrorist). The entire history of right-wing terrorist bombers can be counted on one’s fingers; the Bureau is chasing many times more Moslem terrorist fugitives than that.

Update: The media has an explanation of how the dragnet missed Flashbang in his boat hideaway. The cops searching house-to-house inadvertently skipped that street. Lovely.

Note that this post was inadvertently backdated, it was supposed to go at 0600 May 2. That’s been corrected. Also, the link to Stacy’s post was originally omitted due to an editing error. Also corrected, apologies.

Boston Terrorists had one gun, a 9mm Ruger

Well, so much for all the media stories (which we repeated, damn our eyes) about the armed-to-the-teeth Boston Marathon Bombers. If the media are to be believed now rather than then, it seems that Speedbump had a Ruger 9mm auto pistol, and kid brother Flashbang had… nothing. (There’s also persistent rumor that they had a BB gun of some kind, but this story doesn’t address that). ABC News reports:

Law enforcement sources told ABC News the gun recovered from the scene of the Tsarnaev brothers’ shoot out with police was a Ruger 9 mm semi-automatic handgun. Sources said the gun is in the custody of the Massachusetts State Police lab and that the serial number on the firearm was obliterated.

You may want to  Read The Whole Thing™, as there are a few more details buried in the story, mostly about the defaced serial number and the cops’ confidence that they can recover the number.  The report, though, is silent on what kind of Ruger they had. Ruger has made many 9mm models.

Just for the record, we’d like to clear something up. It seems people in Congress are saying that Tamerlan Tsarnayev (aka Speedbump) would have been denied a chance to buy a gun on the legal market “if the NICS system included people on the terrorist watch lists as prohibited persons” because Speedbump was on one of the various lists. We’ll let others address the constitutional issues. We’ll just make a few facts known:

  • Speedbump already was denied, because he was a Massachusetts resident. To buy most Ruger 9mm pistols, a Mass resident needs a Class A License to Carry. Speedbump didn’t have one.
  • In fact, neither ‘Bump nor ‘Bang had any kind of Mass license, including the Firearms ID card needed to buy long guns, ammo, or model rocket engines (seriously).
  • They couldn’t get the license anyway, because even though Mass is on paper a shall-issue state, their home town, Cambridge, issues only to the politically connected.
  • Speedbump couldn’t get the license anyway because he wasn’t a citizen.
  • Speedbump couldn’t get the license, or pass a background check, because he had a domestic violence conviction. Which is why he couldn’t get his citizenship, either. Come to think of it, it is kind of an indicator of a violent character if a guy beats his woman, no?
  • Flashbang couldn’t get the license because he was under 21.
  • Neither could have honestly bought a gun without perjuring themselves on the form, which asks if one is addicted to or a user of controlled substance. Both were marijuana users (although Speedbump had supposedly quit).
  • Finally, the defacement of the serial numbers on the gun is a strong indicator that the gun was not acquired in lawful commerce. Possession of a firearm with an obliterated serial is a federal and Massachusetts offense in itself. (And for all that, defacing the serial number is futile. Cops have at least two ways to recover it).

Politicians and media wishenhopers need to wake up. These terrorists will not be deterred by the bright line of the law. Last time we looked, making bombs, blowing people up, murdering them, shooting a cop in the back of the head, fleeing law enforcement (a $25 fine in the Mass. General Laws! But still, a law), engaging in firefights, breaking and entering a boat and bleeding all over it, and leaving the scene of a personal injury accident where you ran over your mortally wounded brother, were all against the law already.

We’re not lawyers or anything, but still it looks to us like the question of these guys’ likelihood of following one more law has been well and truly answered. Q.E.D.

“C110″ explained

SFCrestGreenThere’s a lot of nonsense going around the Intertubes today about a super eeee-leeet unit, “C110.” That’s not the prototype of the Mercedes-Benz C111, and it’s not the way-more-powerful update of C4. Supposedly, it’s the Special Forces unit that could have reinforced or rescued the cut-off Americans in the Benghazi consulate, if anybody at the State Department or in the NCA had cared a jot.

Here’s an example at Breitbart and another based on it at Hot Air, based on the a Fox News report. (Warning: both contain loud autoplay malware/adware, try Fox’s own version; it has the same garbage, but loads slowly enough you can read it before the crapware begins).

OK, listen up, blogosphere. That’s Charlie Company, 1st Battalion, 10th Special Forces Group. (C 1/10, pronounced “see one ten.”) It has also been since circa 1984 the Commander’s In-extremis Force (CIF, pronounced “sif”) for Special Operations Command Europe, the theater SOC for the European Command. While there is a separate Africa Command, the North African and other Mediterranean littoral states belong to EuCom. The unit that stands by to rescue hostages and conduct similar high-priority missions, should action be required before national JSOC assets can arrive from their secret North Pole (or somewhere) lair, is the CIF. (Note that it’s “in-extremis force,” not “and extremis force,” which makes no sense but still made it into Fox News’s transcript).

Anonymous sources claimed to be SF speak to the effect that the CIF was available as a reaction force to Benghazi, but was never called and continued a routine training evolution. We can’t address that, but we can tell you what the media types are trying, and failing, to say, terminologically speaking.

Adieu, mes Generals…

exitExit, stage left: Max Boot, who has the perfect name for writing about infantrymen, has an engaging piece at Commentary on how the four most celebrated talented generals in the GWOT recently have followed some of the earlier ones he does not mention (Franks, for example) into the sunset. The last of his four, Marine General Jim Mattis, isn’t quite gone, but he’s standing in the door. Geronimo!

Some of these guys were undone by personal scandals of a trivial sort. Petraeus couldn’t keep his trousers zipped, and McChrystal unwisely gave a reporter access to his staff; the reporter, predictably, betrayed him for a juicier headline. (You can’t blame the reporter for that, really. Item 1: A snake will always bite; that’s the nature of a snake. Item 2: If you’re self-confident enough to join the Church of Jesus Christ of Juggling Snakes, see Item 1). Allen and Mattis? Well, the administration, which doesn’t like the military much, really doesn’t like successful military men, and undermined them at every turn. (It did to the other pair as well, but they gave the administration ammunition). Mattis in particular was resented for leading the Marines as if he had Marine values — as if there was something wrong with that. Boot:

4-star general rankPetraeus, McChrystal, Allen, and Mattis would be the first to deny that they are irreplaceable—the graveyards, they would no doubt remind us, are said to be full of irreplaceable men. And clearly there are a number of capable officers who will strive to fill their combat boots. Some heroes of the last decade of war—including General Ray Odierno, General Martin Dempsey (chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff), Admiral William McRaven (McChrystal’s successor at JSOC and the man who oversaw the Osama bin Laden raid), and Major General H.R. McMaster (a noted military intellectual and counterinsurgency commander)—remain in uniform.

But the experience and savvy of the four will be hard to replace. Certainly they deserve more public appreciation than they have gotten so far and, at the very least, an honored role in helping to teach a new generation of soldiers and Marines how to operate at the pinnacle of command. We do not have such a surplus of brilliant commanders that we can afford to wave away those like Petraeus and McChrystal and Allen and Mattis, who have demonstrated a mastery of the modern battlefield. We can only hope that President Obama’s cavalier attitude toward the loss of their institutional knowledge, their leadership abilities, and their complex understanding of a dangerous world does not prove to be a tragedy for the nation.

Need we advise you to  «Read The Whole Thing™? Or had you already decided to do that? We’ll be here when you come back.

We don’t share Boot’s (or McMaster’s own, for that matter) degree of being impressed with McMaster. Mattis and McChrystal have probably forgotten more about COIN than that publicity hound has ever learnt. But he is talented, even though a bit of a self-promoter. And every corporal and up knows how to handle a “Spotlight Ranger”: keep the spotlight on him, but spread the kudos around enough to ensure his peers don’t get resentful; you’ll get credit for the great things he does, while his personality deficiencies will be his alone. Of course, no one in the NCA, except Chuck Hagel knows this. He’s the only one who’s actually been a corporal, the rest of them lack that character-forging resumé line.

The other guys he mentions vary in quality. Dempsey, for example, is a politician in uniform; while his bosses may curl their toes happily at his sucking-up, his troops wouldn’t cross the street to urinate on him if he were on fire. Odierno has politician tendencies, but in person we found him impressive on several levels. McRaven is the real deal, a good leader for a moral country in a hard world. They are all probably famous enough that the White House resents and will, in time, undermine them, unless they can hang on until the next guy, who will not be so vain and vindictive, whoever he is and whatever party he comes from (or “she” for that matter).

There are many other generals further downlist who bring similar courage, fidelity, and dedication to their tasks. We hesitate to name names, lest we plant targets on their backs. We, as a nation, have always found talented officers, in bad years and under bad Presidents as well as good ones. Some of the best ones “bubble under” at the O-6 (Colonel/Navy Captain) level, but there’s an incredible amount of talent there.

Indeed, the “up-or-out” rule embedded in DOPMA and ROPMA, sucked into the military from 1920s corporate practice — think Durant’s GM — ensures that the path to high rank is an elimination tournament and the Army and other services shed incredible talent at every level.